Bhindi bara rupaye kilo ho gayi hai.

“Bhindi has gone to twelve rupees a kilo.” — Raju Rastogi's mother, 3 Idiots (2009)

Raju's Mummy Bhindi Index

The price history of one kilogram of the vegetable that briefly summarised household economics.

Data confidence: Reconstructed Quote unverified
Film
3 Idiots (2009)
Base year
2009
Indexed unit
One kilogram of bhindi (okra), Delhi retail
Geography
Delhi
Currency
INR

One kilogram of bhindi, quoted at Delhi retail.

Value at 2009

₹22.00

Value at last verified date (2025)

₹55.00

She was presented as dramatic. On the direction of travel she was right — she simply picked the wrong vegetable to be right about.

Nominal change
+150.0%

2009 to 2025, unadjusted

Compound annual growth
+5.9% a year

Across 16 years

2009 value in 2025 money
₹57.98

Base value restated using CPI

Real appreciation
−5.1%

Net of general inflation

Minutes of work, 2009
60 minutes

Per-capita net national income

Minutes of work, 2025
33 minutes

0.6× the 2009 burden

Latest observation
Provisional

The 2025 figure is not yet final. Values on this page will move when it publishes.

Base year — Theatrical release year of 3 Idiots. The film's ₹12 is treated as dialogue, not as an observation — the index is built on the recorded Delhi retail series.

01The series

What it was worth, each year

Nominal local currency by default. Switch modes to strip out inflation, express the figure as earning time, or read it as quantity and percentage change.

Value in the currency of the day, unadjusted.

₹0₹117₹234₹351₹4682009201220152018202120242025Base 20092013: Vegetable price spike2020: Pandemic supply disruption2023: Erratic monsoon

Focus the chart and use ← → to walk the series, Home and End for the ends, Escape to clear.

Bhindi (okra), Delhi retailPaneer, Delhi retailInterpolatedProvisional
One kilogram of bhindi (okra), Delhi retail — Bhindi (okra), Delhi retail: ₹22.00 in 2009, ₹55.00 in 2025 — an increase of 150.0% across 17 annual observations.

Did it outrun the benchmarks?

  • India food CPILagged

    2.5× vs 2.8×

    The right question is not whether bhindi got dearer but whether it outran food inflation generally.

  • India CPI, all groupsLagged

    2.5× vs 2.6×

    Headline inflation, as the benchmark a household actually feels.

  • Per-capita net national incomeLagged

    2.5× vs 4.5×

    Whether the weekly vegetable bill grew faster than the money paying it.

02Calculation

The complete equation

Not a footnote. Every step, every number, the dataset it came from and the rounding rule applied to it.

  1. 1 kg bhindi

    equals the unit named in the scene

    Quantity is not stated in the dialogue; one kilogram is the unit the retail series is quoted in.

  2. 1 × ₹22

    equals value in 2009

    Delhi retail annual average, the film's release year.

    Source: DoCA Price Monitoring

  3. 1 × ₹55

    equals value at last verified date

    2025 Delhi retail annual average. Provisional.

    Source: DoCA Price Monitoring

  4. ₹55 ÷ ₹22

    equals the multiple, compared against food CPI over the same years

    The comparison is the index. The price on its own says very little.

    Source: MoSPI

Conversion — The series is already quoted per kilogram. No conversion is applied.

03Affordability

Price is only the first question

How much it cost, how much the underlying thing appreciated, and how hard it was for a person to afford — three different questions with three different answers.

Time on the clock

How long an average income has to run to cover it.

200960 minutes
202533 minutes

Easier to afford: 0.6× the income burden it carried in 2009 — income grew faster than the price.

What the old money buys

What the 2009 outlay of ₹22.00 would buy at 2025 prices.

2009 prices1 kg of bhindi
2025 prices0.4 kg of bhindi

The same money buys 40.0% of what it did — the rest is price.

Inflation-adjusted value

What the 2009 price is worth in 2025 money, against what the thing actually costs.

2009 price, restated₹57.98
2025 price, actual₹55.00

Real change of −5.1%. Adjusted for inflation it is cheaper than it was, however the nominal price reads.

04Interpretation

What drove the change

Bhindi roughly two-and-a-half-folded between 2009 and 2025. Food prices generally rose faster — the food CPI is up nearer to two-and-four-fifths — so the vegetable she named was not the outlier. It slightly underperformed the basket it belongs to.

Deflate the series by headline CPI and bhindi is close to flat, marginally cheaper in real terms than it was when the film released. Against income it is clearly cheaper: per-capita income grew about four-and-a-half-fold over the same years, which is faster than either food line.

So was she economically correct? On the direction, entirely. On the specific vegetable, less so — and the reason the complaint still lands is that an annual average erases the thing she was actually reacting to. Bhindi swings 40–60% inside a single year. Nobody experiences the annual mean; they experience the July print. That gap between a smooth series and a lived price is the most useful thing this index has to say.

Seasonality, not trend

Bhindi swings 40–60% inside a single year. An annual average hides the months that actually generate the complaint at the vegetable cart.

Weather shocks

Unseasonal rain compresses supply within days. The 2013 and 2023 steps in the series are monsoon events, not structural inflation.

Mandi structure and freight

Retail price includes the APMC chain and transport. Diesel and mandi charges move the retail line without the farm-gate price moving at all.

Household substitution

When one vegetable spikes, households switch. That substitution is why a single-vegetable index reads differently from a food basket.

What this index does not claim

  • The exact wording of the line is not yet verified against the film or authorised subtitles. It is marked unverified on this page until it is.
  • The film's ₹12 is a screenwriter's number. Recorded Delhi retail bhindi in 2009 averaged higher, which is itself a finding rather than a problem.
  • One city, retail only. Mumbai wholesale and all-India CPI quotations are deliberately not spliced into this series.
  • Bhindi is seasonal enough that any annual figure is a summary of a wide range. The seasonal band is shown on the chart rather than smoothed away.
05Provenance

Source ledger

Every dataset behind this page, with the adjustments applied on the way in and how gaps are treated. Last verified 31 December 2025.

  • Retail price of bhindi (okra), Delhi — annual average, ₹ per kgDepartment of Consumer Affairs, Price Monitoring DivisionData confidence: Reconstructed20092025
    Publisher
    Department of Consumer Affairs, Price Monitoring Division
    Date range
    2009-01-01 to 2025-12-31
    Geography
    Delhi
    Frequency
    annual
    Original unit
    ₹ per kg, daily retail quotation, Delhi centre
    Normalised unit
    ₹ per kg, annual mean of monthly means
    Currency
    INR
    Adjustments
    One centre only (Delhi retail) for the whole series — Mumbai wholesale and all-India CPI quotations are never spliced into it. Annual means are computed from monthly means so a volatile monsoon month cannot dominate the year.
    Missing data
    Bhindi is strongly seasonal and thinly reported in the early years. Months missing from the DoCA series are interpolated from the adjacent months of the same year and flagged on the chart.
    Last checked
    2025-12-31
    Licensing
    Public statistics, cited with attribution
  • Retail price of paneer, Delhi — annual average, ₹ per kgDepartment of Consumer Affairs / NDDB market reportsData confidence: Reconstructed20092025
    Publisher
    Department of Consumer Affairs / NDDB market reports
    Date range
    2009-01-01 to 2025-12-31
    Geography
    Delhi
    Frequency
    annual
    Original unit
    ₹ per kg, branded and loose retail blend, Delhi
    Normalised unit
    ₹ per kg, annual mean
    Currency
    INR
    Adjustments
    Paneer is not a DoCA daily-monitored essential for the full period. The series blends branded pack pricing with loose-market quotations, which widens the uncertainty band relative to bhindi.
    Missing data
    Sparse years reconstructed from dairy-federation price circulars.
    Last checked
    2025-12-31
    Licensing
    Public statistics, cited with attribution
  • India consumer food price index — annual average, rebased 2012 = 100MoSPI, Consumer Food Price IndexData confidence: Reconstructed20092025
    Publisher
    MoSPI, Consumer Food Price Index
    Date range
    2009-01-01 to 2025-12-31
    Geography
    India (combined)
    Frequency
    annual
    Original unit
    Index, 2012 = 100
    Normalised unit
    Index, 2012 = 100
    Currency
    INR
    Adjustments
    Pre-2011 values chained from the CPI-IW food group.
    Missing data
    None.
    Last checked
    2025-12-31
    Licensing
    Public statistics, cited with attribution
  • India consumer price index, all groups — annual average, rebased 2012 = 100MoSPI (CPI Combined) spliced to Labour Bureau (CPI-IW)Data confidence: Reconstructed19992025
    Publisher
    MoSPI (CPI Combined) spliced to Labour Bureau (CPI-IW)
    Date range
    1999-01-01 to 2025-12-31
    Geography
    India (combined rural + urban)
    Frequency
    annual
    Original unit
    Index, mixed bases
    Normalised unit
    Index, 2012 = 100
    Currency
    INR
    Adjustments
    CPI Combined begins in 2011. Years before 2011 are back-cast by chaining the CPI-IW growth rate onto the 2012 = 100 base. This splice is the largest single methodological assumption in the Indian indices.
    Missing data
    No gaps. Pre-2011 values are derived, not observed — flagged as such on the chart.
    Last checked
    2025-12-31
    Licensing
    Public statistics, cited with attribution
  • Per-capita net national income at current prices — monthly equivalent, ₹MoSPI, National Accounts StatisticsData confidence: Reconstructed19992025
    Publisher
    MoSPI, National Accounts Statistics
    Date range
    1999-01-01 to 2025-12-31
    Geography
    India
    Frequency
    annual
    Original unit
    ₹ per capita per year, current prices
    Normalised unit
    ₹ per capita per month
    Currency
    INR
    Adjustments
    Annual figure divided by 12. Per-capita NNI is a national average across the whole population, not a wage — it understates urban salaried income and overstates rural. Read the affordability rows as a direction of travel, not a payslip.
    Missing data
    Fiscal years mapped to their starting calendar year. The 2025 value is a provisional advance estimate.
    Last checked
    2025-12-31
    Licensing
    Public statistics, cited with attribution

Pop Indices is editorial and educational. Historical returns are described, never projected, and nothing here is investment advice. Film titles, characters and dialogue are referenced for commentary and remain the property of their rights holders.

Take it with you

The card carries its own provenance

A figure that travels without its source is the thing this section exists to avoid, so the export always includes the credit line.

Share
1080 × 1080 · square posts everywhere